If you’re worried about U.S. manufacturing jobs, pay no attention to Ford’s recent decision to move production of the Focus compact car to China.
Building Focuses in suburban Detroit, as Ford does today, is not good career planning, whether you’re a UAW assembly worker or newly named Ford president of global operations Joe Hinrichs.
Keep your eye on Ford’s upcoming Eco Sport subcompact SUV, and an as yet unnamed compact SUV Ford is expected to introduce in a couple of years.
In the game of industrial three-card monte automakers play as they shuffle production from one plant to another, SUVs are the winning card.
That’s no surprise to the workers who build the Focus in Wayne, just west Ford global headquarters in Dearborn. Their jobs will probably be more secure when the Focus departs for China, taking with it the razor-thin profit margins of building a compact car in the U.S.
Focus production in Wayne will end about a year from now.
A few months later, the workers who built the Focus and an array of its slow-selling derivatives will begin producing an all-new Ranger midsize pickup, belatedly giving Ford a competitor for the popular Chevrolet Colorado, Honda Ridgeline and Toyota Tacoma. A year after that, Wayne will add a second truck for which Ford has high hopes, a new version of the Bronco off-roading SUV.
The first Ford Focus rolled off a production line in northeast China's Heilongjiang province on Wednesday, February 22, 2017. The factory, in Harbin, capital of Heilongjiang, has an annual production capacity of 200,000 and is Changan Ford's fifth in the country. (Photo: Yang Liu, Imaginechina)
Ford took its sweet time deciding to build the Ranger, but if the company did its job, the midsize pickup and SUV will sell at much higher prices than the Focus, improving the company bottom line and workers’ job security. And if the Ranger and Bronco are a success there is a good chance that plant will eventually employ more workers than it does now.
“The Wayne plant will be more secure with the new vehicles than it ever was with the Focus,” Autotrader senior analyst Michelle Krebs said.
The initial fuss when Ford said it would move Focus production to China — like a lot of political and economic debate — was public figures fighting the last war. The conviction that Asian intruders will snatch American jobs with cheap imports belongs to another generation, not the era of global automaking.
“This is not a matter of closing a U.S. factory in favor of China,” IHS Markit senior analyst Stephanie Brinley said. “The factory in Michigan is getting a couple of new products that could be more popular. Ford is not closing a plant.”
Equally important, Ford is moving production of a low-profit vehicle in a declining market segment out of the U.S. The Ranger and Bronco will likely be more complicated than the Focus, with more model variations and more suppliers making parts nearby. All that is good for employment. If either vehicle is a hit, the plant could even need overtime or more workers.
Ford Executive Vice President and President of the Americas for Ford Motor Company, Joe Hinrichs announces plans for a 2020 Bronco at the North American International Auto show in January 2017 in Detroit. (Photo: Carlos Osorio, AP)
That’s a remote possibility for any U.S. plant building compact cars like the Focus.
General Motors' plant in Lordstown, Ohio, builds the Chevy Cruze compact, a newer car than the Focus that’s been praised for its quality, technology and performance. Despite that, Lordstown has laid off one shift this year and will shut down for three weeks. Sales of all types of cars are falling as U.S. buyers switch to SUVs and trucks.
Focus sales are down 19.8% this year after falling 16.4% in 2016. That’s not a glide path, it’s a nosedive and Ford clearly doesn’t care.
The automaker won’t introduce an all-new Focus in the U.S. until the second half of 2019, after at least a yearlong hiatus in production and a shift to the new factory in China. It’s a safe bet that few buyers will even notice the lack of new Focuses during the break. Demand for small cars is evaporating. That’s why Ford canceled ill-considered plans to build a new Focus plant in Mexico earlier this year.
Ford will save about $500 million by retooling just the Chinese plant for the new model rather than a second plant in the U.S.
“Every automaker is re-evaluating its investment in cars versus SUVS,” Krebs said. “If there’s a border tax, that’ll change the math, but Ford says they built that into the plan.”
That’s what it means to be a global automaker — building and selling vehicles around the world. Inevitably, a lot of vehicles aren’t built in the company’s home market, but the alternative is being a little fish in a big pond, prey that may be devoured at any time. (See: DaimlerChrysler's troubled years and Fiat Chrysler Automobiles' continued challenges.)
“Ford is not turning away from the U.S. It’s still a huge market and a key manufacturing base for them,” Brinley said.
If you’re looking for a harbinger of U.S. auto manufacturing, watch where Ford and GM build a couple of key upcoming SUVs.
The EcoSport subcompact that Ford will be importing from India to the U.S. beginning next year is a sideshow, but it leads to the main attraction. The current EcoSport was designed for developing markets; an examination of its design, features, materials and specifications reveals that it’s a stopgap vehicle because Ford underestimated U.S. desires for SUVs and didn’t develop one to sell here.
Even the next-generation EcoSport is a long shot for North American production, but another small SUV Ford is believed to have in the works for two or three years from now should be a candidate for U.S. production.
The big potential wins for U.S. automaking are that Ford SUV and the next generation of the Buick Envision, a compact luxury SUV that GM currently imports from China.
2017 Buick Envision (Photo: Buick)
The Envision was already a hit in China when U.S. sales began last summer. Buick sold 14,193 Envisions in the U.S. last year and 22,620 so far this year. That’s just 7,200 fewer than Cadillac sold of the U.S.-made XT5 SUV through June. If Envision sales continue to rise, they could reach the point where adding U.S. production to the existing Chinese plant makes sense.
Don’t be surprised if the next-generation Envision and new Ford SUV are carrots automakers dangle in front of unions during the next round of contract talks as well as state development agencies as they look for tax breaks.
American manufacturing is more competitive today than in generations, largely because of cheap, clean energy thanks to the natural gas boom. That may translate to an increase in U.S. carmaking, but you’ll never know if you focus on where global automakers build compact cars.