WASHINGTON D.C., DC — A new report by the VA’s Inspector General criticizes the Department of Veterans Affairs for improperly denying millions of dollars in emergency medical bill claims by veterans nationwide.
The report estimated that “31 percent of denied or rejected non-VA emergency care claims were inappropriately processed …”
The Office of the Inspector General report audited emergency medical claims processed over a six-month period in 2017. It found: “The billed amount of inappropriately processed claims from April 1 through September 30, 2017, that were denied or rejected was large in the aggregate—an estimated $716 million—and presented potential undue financial risk to an estimated 60,800 veterans.”
Although veterans can appeal denials, the Inspector General (OIG) estimated that veterans may be short-changed by “$533 million in improper underpayments to claimants over five years.”
The report was prompted by investigations by 11Alive and our sister station, KARE 11’s Pattern of Denial investigation launched in 2017. KARE 11 quoted VA whistleblowers who said it was faster to deny claims than to approve them.
“We are accountable for speed,” one VA insider told KARE 11. “And the faster you are, the more your performance goes up.”
The OIG report confirmed that finding. The audit found that the VA “placed more emphasis on the number of claims processed than the accuracy of the claims decisions.”
MORE: Read the full report
KARE 11’s reports prompted then-Congressman Tim Walz (D-Minn.) to request a full investigation in September 2017. Walz wrote that he was concerned the VA had “created perverse incentives for its claims processors to deny veterans’ emergency care claims.”
In February 2018, an 11Alive Investigation uncovered the VA denied paying for thousands of emergency room visits for Georgia veterans over the past few years. It’s not because the veterans did not have an emergency, it's because they did not visit a VA doctor enough.
Army veteran David Riggs is one of those veterans. Last year, the 55-year-old Brooklet, Georgia veteran went to the ER at East Georgia Regional Medical Center in Statesboro for kidney stones.
A few months later, he received a bill from the hospital for $12,186. At first, Riggs wasn’t worried because he’s covered by the VA. So, he was surprised when he got a letter in the mail from the VA denying his claim because “he had not received VA treatment within the past 24 months prior to the emergency room visit.”
“My reaction to that was, 'Well, I didn’t know this rule was in effect,'" explained Riggs. “I’m being penalized for being healthy and not having to use the doctor very often.”
The 11Alive Investigators uncovered evidence that Riggs isn’t the only veteran who’s never heard of the rule. A 2014 Government Accountability Office report found that “most veterans” are ”not knowledgeable about the Millennium Act.”
11Alive discovered the VA denied at least 7,132 ER claims in Georgia due to the 24-month rule, costing veterans more than $29 million. Nationally, the numbers jump to 219,681 ER claims, with a $791 million price tag.