Breaking News
More () »

Lawsuit filed against Cobb County Sheriff to release records on jail deaths

The department has denied 11Alive access to public records under the Georgia Open Records Act. The cases were previously closed by the department.

COBB COUNTY, Ga. — 11Alive has filed court documents asking a judge to immediately compel the Cobb County Sheriff’s office to produce records its withholding from the public.

The requested hearing follows a lawsuit 11Alive filed against Sheriff Neil Warren, which alleges his department has violated the Georgia Open Records Act in an attempt to conceal documents related to jail deaths.

In August, 11Alive's investigative team, The Reveal, submitted a records request seeking case files involving three inmates who died at the Cobb County Detention Center.

The requested documents included criminal and internal affairs case files previously closed by sheriff investigators. The former inmates include Reginald Wilson, found unresponsive on Dec. 29, 2018; Bradley Emory, found unresponsive on March 10, 2019 and Stephanie McClendon, found dead this past June.

The sheriff, who is running for re-election, declined to produce the documents because he claimed the inmate deaths were still under investigation, not by law enforcement, but private attorney Nathan Wade.

RELATED: 'I can't breathe': Man dies in custody after hours of begging for help

According to the complaint filed in Cobb County Superior Court on Thursday, “Mr. Wade is a not a law enforcement officer or investigator; he is a private attorney who has no apparent experience, qualifications, or training in conducting jailhouse investigations and no bona fide investigative authority.”

Through records requests, 11Alive and its attorneys identified no documents defining the scope and purpose of Wade’s investigation or any letter of engagement, which typically outlines the work an attorney is hired to perform.

The county says Wade is also doing the work free of charge. 

“There is an exception that allows law enforcement agencies to withhold records that are part of a legitimate criminal investigation, but that is not intended to allow an elected law enforcement officer to withhold potentially unflattering documents to the public in the run off to an election,” said Ian Byrnside, one of the attorneys representing 11Alive. 

The lawsuit outlines that Wade has represented the Sheriff Neil Warren in personal matters in the past.

“At the suggestion of Cobb County Chief Deputy Sheriff Sonya Allen - who is Mr. Wade’s former classmate and friend - Mr. Wade represented Sheriff Warren in his personal capacity at a hearing before the Cobb County Board of Elections earlier this year, and defended Sheriff Warren against allegations made by a former Democratic challenger that Sheriff Warren did not notarize his original qualifying documents,” the lawsuit said.

 READ | The full lawsuit 11Alive filed 

11Alive’s attempts to obtain the jail death records follows a series of the Reveal investigations exposing the death of former inmate Kevil Wingo. Video and documents released from his case file this past June show Wingo repeatedly begged to be sent to the hospital after suffering from stomach pain and difficulty breathing for at least seven hours.

Instead of sending him to the hospital, jail and medical staff placed Wingo in a padded room, where he later died alone. The medical examiner ruled his death natural, caused by a torn ulcer.

Since 11Alive’s investigation, two law enforcement agencies have been asked to take another look at the circumstances surrounding Wingo’s death and other inmate fatalities.

RELATED: After 11Alive investigation revealed heartbreaking video of man's death, case gets a second look

Since our investigation, the Cobb County District Attorney asked the U.S. Attorney’s office to open a federal investigation into recent jail deaths at the detention center. And on Aug. 27, the sheriff requested the Georgia Bureau of Investigation conduct an administrative review of Cobb County’s original investigation. 

At least two nurses who worked the evening Wingo died have been put on administrative leave.

11Alive asked the sheriff’s office if it would like to comment on the lawsuit, the GBI review or the district attorney’s investigative request, but did not get a response.

According to the county medical examiner’s office, at least 51 people have died while in custody at the jail since 2004. One of those deaths includes an inmate’s newborn baby which died during childbirth.

In response to the Reveal’s investigation into Wingo’s death, Cindi Yeager, a criminal defense attorney, wrote an editorial published in August in the Marietta Daily Journal demanding the DA request an independent investigation and criticizing Sheriff Neil Warren for not taking action himself.

"Since the editorial, I’ve gotten three to five letters or more every day from inmates complaining of the treatment that they’re getting, the fact they’re not allowed out of their cells,” said Yeager. 

11Alive has asked a judge to hold a hearing on the issue in the next 30 days. The November 3 election is 39 days away.

The Reveal is an investigative show exposing inequality, injustice, and ineptitude created by people in power throughout Georgia and across the country.    


Georgia Judge rules evidence 'inherently unreliable', freeing woman from prison after 15 years

Nursing home where woman was 'eaten alive' by mites receives over $8M in taxpayer money

Teen boys on demand: DFCS unknowingly supplied sex victims to foster mom

City officials block access to evidence in deadly hit and run and alleged cover up, says attorney 

Before You Leave, Check This Out