Breaking News
More () »

Atlanta's Leading Local News: Weather, Traffic, Sports and more | Atlanta, Georgia | 11alive.com

'Sexist pig' vs. 'makes sense': Atlanta United manager revives contentious equal pay debate

Frank de Boer's remarks generated a wide range of responses.

ATLANTA — Atlanta United manager Frank de Boer waded into one of the most contentious topics in sports, and in American society generally, when he called the idea of paying men’s and women’s soccer players “ridiculous.” 

He made the comments to The Guardian, in an interview published on Tuesday. 

The debate is often confused – soccer players earn their pay from a number of different sources, and the U.S. Women’s National Team, in a lawsuit, and their advocates have largely targeted their criticism at the U.S. Soccer Federation over the equal pay issue.

De Boer’s comments referenced the World Cup, which is operated by FIFA.

Nevertheless, they reopened clear divides on the subject, as reflected in the wide range of responses to his comments.

RELATED: Atlanta United manager says equal pay for women in sport 'ridiculous'

Some were angry – “he’s a sexist pig!” – and some were in agreement – “makes sense, totally agree.”

Many came from women frustrated at De Boer’s disregard.

“This is the exact mentality women face every single day,” one Twitter user, Jen O'Donnell, wrote to 11Alive. “What makes men so great?”

“I’m sad that we need a new coach now #fireatlunitedcoach,” wrote Stephanie Owens.

The counter to these sentiments were, in many instances, appeals to economics.

“He’s looking at it from a business standpoint and not an ‘equal rights’ standpoint,” Daniel White wrote on Facebook.

The business element can be difficult to parse. Members of the U.S. women’s and men’s teams both draw salaries from the U.S. Soccer Federation – Carlos Cordeiro, the president of the federation, has claimed the women in fact have gotten paid more.

A spokeswoman for the players in the lawsuit, Molly Levinson, has argued that pay figures released by the federation are deliberately misleading. She said that “for every game a man plays on the MNT, he makes a higher base salary payment than a woman on the WNT.”

RELATED: US Soccer says women's team has made more than the men

One Twitter user, Sarah Ingman, wrote it’s the formula that needs to be equal.

“I believe that the base pay for the women should be the same. I do not know how the bonuses and profit sharing of proceeds work, but the women should get the same % as men,” she wrote. “If the total is the same, then so be it, but the formula should be the same.”

According to figures cited by 11Alive’s Cheryl Preheim, that total is not the same – it is in fact higher for the women.

Between 2016-2018, according to the figures, the women’s games generated $50.8 million in ticket sales revenue, about $1 million more than the men.

And this year’s Women’s World Cup final this year was seen by 22 percent more viewers, at least in the U.S., than the Men’s World Cup final was seen by last summer.

De Boer made clear his thoughts didn’t extend to the business world or other areas.

“I think if you have a manager position for a bank or something, you have to earn the same what the men did because it’s not physically, just only here [points to head],” he said.

The manager referenced the much larger global audience for men’s soccer, compared to women’s soccer, as one element justifying his views.

But another Facebook user pointed out how difficult this all is to resolve:

“The premise makes sense. Make more, we’ll pay you more,” Daniel White wrote. “Here’s the rub: it’s a vicious cycle. The only way to get more fan attention is to give women’s sports equal cover on tv, in the news, etc. That won’t get that because media outlets don’t see them as being profitable, because sponsors and advertisers won’t pay as much for women’s sports. Advertisers won’t pay more until interest goes up.”

“And on and on into eternity until something gives,” she added.


Senator wants to block 2026 World Cup funding until equal pay for US Soccer teams

'Equal pay! Equal pay!' World Cup crowd breaks into chant after U.S. women win title match

U.S. women's soccer team files lawsuit for equal pay